UConn students arrested for 'ridiculing' speech won't face discipline...for now

  • A federal judge has temporarily blocked the University of Connecticut from holding disciplinary hearings for the two students arrested for using racial slurs.
  • The decision came just days after the two students sued UConn, alleging free speech violations.

A federal judge blocked the University of Connecticut from issuing punishment to the two students arrested in October for using racial slurs.

Ryan Mucaj and Jarred Karal sued the university on January 14 alleging their constitutional rights to free speech were violated, as Campus Reform reported. The lawsuit came not long after a separate court ordered probation for Karal,  including 20 hours of community service and completion of diversity and sensitivity training, as Campus Reform also reported. Mucaj's case was still ongoing. 

Free speech advocates have decried the university's handling of the situation, and the Connecticut law under which the two were charged.   

While the status of Karal's probation is uncertain, a federal court has meanwhile stepped in to prevent UConn from holding student disciplinary hearings, at least for now. Before the injunction, the two students had faced eviction from campus housing before their case even went to trial. 

[RELATED: UConn students ARRESTED for 'ridiculing' speech in viral video]

Judge Michael Shea at the U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut issued the following ruling on Thursday: 

"It is HEREBY ORDERED that the defendants, their officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys, and any other persons who are in active concert or participation with them, are ENJOINED from conducting the Plaintiffs' disciplinary hearing scheduled for January 17, 2020, and are further ENJOINED from imposing any disciplinary sanctions against the Plaintiffs stemming from the October 11, 2019 incident including, without limitation, termination of the Plaintiffs' campus housing, until the Court rules on the Plaintiffs’ alternative motion for preliminary injunction following a hearing scheduled for January 28, 2020

Free speech advocates have decried the university's handling of the situation, and the Connecticut law under which the two were charged.

[RELATED: UConn student arrested for saying n-word must complete community service, bias training]

UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh has called the statute "obviously unconstitutional" while the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education has pointed out that the "First Amendment protects offensive language, and neither the University of Connecticut nor its police officers may abridge students' First Amendment rights," as Campus Reform also previously reported

Follow the author of this article on Facebook: @JonStreetDC and Twitter: @JonStreet

Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Jon Street
Jon Street | Managing Editor

Jon Street is a news editor for Campus Reform. Six years ago, Jon cut his reporting teeth fresh out of college as an intern at Media Research Center's CNSNews.com, where he interviewed multiple members of Congress and former presidential candidates. From there, he went on to complete a stint at Watchdog.org, where his exclusive, investigative work was picked up or cited by the New York Times, Washington Post, Fox News, National Review, and the Drudge Report, among others. More recently, Jon spent three years as an assistant editor at TheBlaze.com. In his free time, Jon enjoys trying new coffeehouses around the Washington, D.C. metropolitan area and traveling back to his home state of Missouri to spend time with his family.

20 Articles by Jon Street